I Love Chief O’Brien, But I Don't Want Him To Come Back To Star Trek

Summary

Star Trek : Deep Space Nine ’s Chief O’Brien ( Colm Meaney ) is my favoriteStar Trekcharacter , but I do n’t desire him to fall to the franchise . IDW’sStar Trekcomics have recently brought back Chief O’Brien inStar Trek Annual 2024 , which reunite him with Lt . Commander Data ( Brent Spiner ) and Lt . Commander Geordi La Forge ( LeVar Burton ) for a raw adventure . you may make your own decisiveness about whether O’Brien ’s funny account book counter is canon or not , but it does prove the doubt of whether Colm Meaney could , or should , return toStar Trek .

In a 2021 interview withCBR , Colm Meaney enounce that he had mixed feelings about returning toStar Trekin case " things stop up being ruined . “Star Trek : Picardseason 3 leaven that the modern dealership has writers who care about these legacy part , and put serious opinion into how their lives have developed in the meantime . AfterPicardseason 3 revealed that the Borg had assimilated Starfleet via the transporters , I was convinced that Chief O’Brien would render to save the twenty-four hour period . That did n’t come about , and on contemplation , I ’m glad Colm Meaney ’s belovedStar Trek : DS9characterhasn’t return .

DS9 ’s Colm Meaney is one of the practiced actor to appear in Star Trek and these brilliant persona expose the depth of the iconic Chief O’Brien star .

Custom image by Mark Donaldson

Chief O’Brien Shouldn’t Come Back To Star Trek - He’s Suffered Enough

O’Brien must suffer no more.

I do n’t want Chief O’Brien to return toStar Trekbecause it could seriously undermine his felicitous ending inStar Trek : Deep Space Nine . After seven seasons of juggling family life-time with the stresses of keeping a space station operational during a crushing intergalactic war , Chief O’Brien lastly got to relax . At the destruction ofDS9 , the O’Briens left the place for a young life-time on Earth , wherethe Chief would learn at Starfleet Academy . It was the perfect conclusion for a kinsfolk man like Miles O’Brien , so throwing him back into the thick of the action would surely jeopardize his peaceful new spirit .

… after being tortured by Cardassians , witnessing his own death , and enduring decades in prison , Chief O’Brien has endure enough .

As an enlisted human beings , Chief O’Brien more than serve his metre duringStar Trek : Deep Space Nine , so I genuinely think he deserve his retirement . Dragging the Chief out of the Academy to forefend yet another intergalactic crisis would of necessity lead to moreO’Brien must suffer instalment , because that ’s whatStar Trekfans would expect . This would be a immense misunderstanding because , after being tortured by Cardassians , witnessing his own demise , and enduring decades in prison , Chief O’Brien has suffered enough . I really hope thatmodernStar Trekjust lets O’Brien enjoy his quiet life as an Academy teacher .

How Chief O’Brien Could Return To Star Trek Without Ruining His DS9 Ending

There ’s emphatically a agency to bring back Chief O’Brien without ruin his conclusion inStar Trek : Deep Space Nine . I fuck I ’d enjoy a wryly comic cameo in the final season ofStar Trek : Lower deck , which has previously nominate Chief O’Brien as " the most significant man in Starfleet history . “Colm Meaney is a man with a expectant sense of liquid body substance , so I can definitely see him agreeing to a smallLower Deckscameo if the book was right . Also on the animation front , a sneaky cameo by Professor O’Brien at Starfleet Academy inStar Trek : Prodigywould be a fun way to nod to the character while honour his ending .

A more leftfield way to contribute Chief O’Brien back toStar Trekwould be as a hologram in theupcomingStar Trek : Starfleet Academyshow . InStar Trek : Discoveryseason 5 , it was unveil that holographic applied science was extremely advanced , allowing Doctor Hugh Culber ( Wilson Cruz ) to interact with his grandmother . Therefore , Star Trek : Deep Space Nine ’s Chief O’Brien could be uprise as a holographical instructor , put the next generation of engine room cadets through their paces . However , I ’d still prefer to think of Chief O’Brien experience a peaceful aliveness on Earth with his family .